Why you still act like the self you’re trying to outgrow


This week's JournalingFix newsletter:

  • The reason you can know exactly what to do and still not do it
  • How your nervous system steers you to the “old you” even when you’re over it
  • A 5‑minute writing protocol to help
  • What's coming April 23

Hey everyone,

Let's be honest: for a lot of things in our lives, we know what we want. We know what "better" looks like. We can even list the actions that would really move the needle.

But if we look at our week, it still feels like we're running on repeat.

  • Maybe we say we want calmer evenings, but we're still answering "one more thing" at 9:30 and scrolling at 11:30, then lying there wired and resentful that tomorrow is already compromised.
  • Maybe we want to be the person who follows through, but we're living inside a landscape of 80%‑finished projects that erodes our self‑trust every time we see the list.
  • Maybe we say we're done overcommitting, but our calendar still looks like we said yes to three different lives, so even on days off we feel behind.

Those gaps between what we say we want and how we're actually operating aren't about intelligence or effort. It's identity lag.


What's really going on

Our nervous system treats our current patterns as "home base," even if they're not ideal.

The way we've always worked, always responded to requests, always handled nights and weekends - that lives in our system as familiar and therefore "safe enough." Our brains prefer familiar patterns because they’re easier to predict and cheaper to run; even if a new way of operating is “better,” it costs more energy and feels less certain at first. The version of us who does things differently is less familiar. Which means our system flags it as questionable.

When something feels even slightly unsafe or unproven, our brain will steer us back to what it already knows how to do - even if we consciously want something different.

We can understand habit loops, goal setting, dopamine, all of it… and still watch ourselves replay the same Thursday.


What can help us shift from that?

We start to operate differently when our brain can:

  1. See the version of ourselves we're training toward clearly enough that it's not an abstract ‘better person,’ but a specific way of operating.
  2. File that version as plausible and safe, instead of fantasy or threat.
  3. Accumulate real evidence that we already act like 'them' in small ways.

That's where writing comes in.

Our brain encodes identity through the stories we repeat, the data points we highlight, and the moments we decide "this is who I am" versus "this is just a pattern I've been running."

If those stories and data points never change, our identity doesn't either.


A 5‑minute protocol to start closing the gap

If you have five minutes, try this on paper (actually write! it's what works):

Step 1: Name the version that’s driving today

At the top of the page, write: “Right now I’m operating like the version of me who…”

Finish that sentence with specifics.
Examples: “who says yes to everything,” “who overthinks instead of doing,” “who pushes off tasks that will move my goal forward.”

Step 2: Name the version you’re actually trying to be

Underneath, write: “The version of me I’m actually trying to be is the one who…”

Write specifics.
What boundaries do you protect? What do you say no to? How do you treat your time, sleep, attention, relationships?

You now have two clear identities on the page.

Step 3: Find one decision point today

Write: “One moment today where these two versions of me would handle things differently is…”

Then think of a specific moment on your actual schedule where you usually wobble between “old me” and “the version of me I want running my days.”

For example:

  • When a focus block hits 20 minutes in and you usually “just check” email or Slack.
  • When you sit down to work and feel the pull to start a new idea instead of finishing the thing that’s already half done.
  • When someone pings you with a “quick” request that will eat the hour you set aside for deep work.

Step 4: Pre‑decide the move

Example:

“When I hit that moment, I'll act like the version of me I want running my days by:
‘Keeping Slack closed until the block is over,’ or
‘Parking the new idea in my notes and finishing the current deliverable first.’”

Write yours down.

That’s it.

You’re using writing to make two versions of you visible, pick one real fork in the road today, and rehearse the move your future self would actually make - so when you hit that moment, your brain already has a script.

It gives your nervous system a concrete example of "this is something we do now," so that version of you moves from concept to pattern.

And you can practice this any time you feel that gap between what you say you want and how you’re operating - new day, new fork in the road, same 5‑minute protocol.


JournalingFix OS opens April 23.

It's built for high performers who are tired of running on max effort and still feeling like they're leaving capacity, money, and impact on the table because their own brain is the choke point.

It’s not a journal or a course. It’s a writing‑based internal operating system:

  • A simple diagnostic map so you can tell what state you’re in and which protocol to run.
  • A library of short, situation‑specific writing protocols for overload, avoidance, nighttime spirals, and identity wobble.
  • Implementation guides so these tools actually live inside your real week, not just in a PDF.


It’s designed to help you clear mental overload, change who’s actually running your days, and handle the exact moments you usually default to the old pattern - so you can operate at the level you already know you’re capable of. Details coming next week.

As always, reach out any time with questions or feedback.

-- Áine

JournalingFix Newsletter

Brain science based micro-writing prompts to get unstuck, think clearly, and follow through - so you can close the gap between what you're capable of and how your days actually go. Stop losing time and energy to the same loops, avoidance, and mental spin - and then use those shifts to build what’s next.

Read more from JournalingFix Newsletter

Hi, it’s Áine. I used to have a lot of shoulds in my life. I should make that appointment. I should follow up with them. I should start that project. I should go to that thing. If you, too, have a lot of shoulds, this might help. It turns out that when we think and say these types of "should" things, our brains hear a threat. “Should” usually carries two signals at once: That we’re failing some standard (we’re not enough yet). That we have a vague instruction with no clear first step. That...

This week's JournalingFix Newsletter: Why a 10‑minute task can sit on your list for a week (or more) The brain science behind “I’ll do it later” A 4‑step reset to finally get it done JournalingFix workshops and events Hi, it’s Áine at JournalingFix. You know the task. It’s been on your list for three days. Maybe longer. It would take ten minutes. Maybe twenty. And yet every time you look at it, something in you just... doesn’t. What’s actually happening Your brain doesn’t just evaluate tasks...

This week’s JournalingFix newsletter: – Why your best ideas show up in the shower (and don’t come back when you need them)– 4 quick writing steps to get brilliant ideas back on track– How to turn “lost” ideas into something you can use later Hi, it’s Áine. You know those brilliant ideas we all get when we’re in the shower, on a walk, driving, pretty much anywhere we can’t do something about them? They’re so sharp and obvious in the moment. I always think, “There’s no way I’ll forget this.”...